Capitalism loves to tell us that it’s a meritocracy in which hard work, determination, and ingenuity pay off. For some, this is true. For many, it’s not. For the millions of middle- and lower-income families who do the same jobs year after year after year while struggling to get by, “Capitalism” actually refers to a series of hidden systems designed to keep them just where they are. Let’s discuss exactly what I mean, using real-life examples.
The Debt Cycle
It is hard for many families to avoid debt in a system in which wages do not keep up with rising housing, healthcare, and education costs. To stay afloat, people take out credit cards, personal loans, or student loans.
Example:
A young professional earning $45,000 per year needs $20,000 in student loans to get the degree required for the job she’s able to land. She takes out a car loan to buy a vehicle for commuting. She uses her credit cards for some unexpected expenses and now has a balance of $1,500. When you throw in those monthly payments (especially the interest charges), a huge chunk of the paycheck is now just servicing debt, rather than going into savings and investments. For every dollar a person spends on interest, it’s a dollar they can’t put into an index fund or emergency savings account.
The end result is a treadmill effect. People work longer hours or get additional jobs, but they aren’t actually improving their situation because so much of their increased income goes to banks and lenders.
Housing: The Wealth Divide Multiplier
Owning a home is how the vast majority of wealth in developed countries is created. But the system is rigged to encourage middle- and lower-income families to rent rather than build equity.
Example:
A family of four spends $2,000 a month in rent. That’s enough to pay their landlord’s mortgage payment (plus profits), but at the end of the year, the landlord owns a piece of property worth maybe a million dollars while the renter has nothing to show for it. If the landlord sells, they might take home $500,000 in profits. (The family, on the other hand, paid $24,000 in rent for the year. Zero equity.)
In the meantime, higher-income families who can scrape together a 20% down payment benefit from:
- Home appreciation
- Mortgage tax deduction
- Owning a valuable asset when the mortgage is paid off
These are a few of the reasons why housing is one of the biggest factors in upward mobility. If you can’t get ahead with your first dollar, it is harder to catch up with your tenth.
The Healthcare Trap
In nations without universal healthcare, medical costs are one of the most rapid routes to poverty. For middle-income earners with insurance, high deductibles and co-pays can easily consume a large part of savings.
Example:
A teacher earns $60,000 per year but faces an $8,000 medical bill for emergency surgery. The out-of-pocket cost is the only amount the insurance covers after a high deductible is met. The family has an emergency fund of $7,000 but is now forced to charge the balance on a credit card. One medical emergency and it’s back to zero (plus credit card debt).
Medical expenses are not just costs; they are random financial landmines that are far more likely to devastate people without wealth buffers.
Wages Stagnate as Inflation Increases
In a system where corporate profits are all-time highs, wages for the majority have stagnated over the past several decades.
Example:
In the U.S., median wages have increased by 17% (adjusted for inflation) since 1979. During the same period, the cost of healthcare increased 145%, housing 121%, and college tuition almost 200%.
The end result is that middle- and lower-income families work hard and might receive modest raises, but they are losing ground because of inflation on the things they need to live and work.
Predatory Lending and Financial Products
Targeted at lower-income and less financially literate people, this includes high-interest personal loans, payday lenders, and “buy now, pay later” credit cards.
Example:
A family takes out a payday loan for $400 to cover an unexpected expense like groceries for the week. The lender charges a $60 fee but also requires it to be paid back by the next paycheck. The $460 “loan” is paid back but must be re-borrowed to cover the same expenses. The annual percentage rate (APR) for this payday loan could be 300% or more if those terms are extended (increasing from $400 to $1,000 owed in just a few months). At this point, it’s impossible to get out of the cycle.
The Illusion of “Choice”
Capitalism is all about the supposed freedom of choice. But in reality, the range of “choices” middle- and lower-income groups have are extremely limited by structural factors.
Desire a better job? Fine, but you may need an advanced degree (more debt).
Eat healthy food? It’s almost always more expensive than fast food. For punishment, you’re further punished by “price-sensitive” markets that cater to your “choice” to eat poorly.
Invest and buy assets? Impossible without spare income to put in the first place.
Wealthy people are given choices that compound their wealth. The rest of us are given choices that multiply stress and risk.
Why This Trap Keeps Us Trapped
It is hard for me to overstate how the system entrenches itself.
Intergenerational Wealth (and Debt): Rich families pass along both assets and the education and connections to increase them. Poorer families pass down financial instability, debt, and a scarcity mindset.
Policy: Corporations and the wealthy lobby for tax rates and policies that protect and grow their wealth (capital gains taxes, loopholes, bailouts) but have little to no power when it comes to laws that affect wage earners.
Cultural Narratives: The self-made, bootstrap-wearing rich person is glorified. Every kid growing up hears this. Poverty is a personal failure (lazy, low IQ, or mentally weak) rather than a systemic issue.
Breaking Capitalism Wealth Trap (To the Degree That It’s Possible)
Of course, the middle- and lower-income group is not doomed to failure. Building financial literacy and “smart” money habits, avoiding high-interest debt, and slowly saving to buy assets (even if it’s just index funds) can help. But only on a structural level will meaningful change require policies to close the wealth gap, increase the affordability of education and healthcare, and prevent predatory lending.
Bottom Line
Capitalism is not a bad system. Left unchecked, however, it becomes a way for the top 1% to get even richer while making it harder and harder for the 99% to do more than tread water. This isn’t a question of whether people are working hard enough. This is a question of whether the system is set up so that their hard work actually pays off.
Keep learning: courses on this topic
Self-paced courses to put this article into practice.
Udemy
Complete Personal Finance Course: Earn, Save and Invest
A self-paced video course on budgeting, saving and investing, with practical lessons you can apply right away.
View course
Udemy
Master Personal Finance: Build Wealth, Save & Invest Money
Have Better Finances To Save & Invest Money Building Wealth, Clear Loans, Debts & Credit Cards To Reach Your Financial Goals ! Note: This…
View course
Udemy
Invest Like a Pro: Your First Steps in Wealth Creation
A self-paced video course on budgeting, saving and investing and investing basics, with practical lessons you can apply right away.
View course
Leave a Comment